Stories Videos The Web  
    CBS Evening News [ Watch Now ]  |  The Early Show  |  48 Hours  |  60 Minutes  |  CBS Sunday Morning  |  Face The Nation  |  Up To The Minute  |  Video: Build A Playlist


Section Front

60 Minutes Main Page60 Minutes Main Page
60 Minutes Video60 Minutes Video
Program FactsProgram Facts
BiosBios
Andy RooneyAndy Rooney
Contact InfoContact Info
Up NextUp Next
Tapes and TranscriptsTapes and Transcripts
DVDs from Amazon.comDVDs from Amazon.com

Wireless Alerts
E-Mail Alerts
Podcasts
RSS Feeds

Related Information:
Read the Army statement on U.S. Army and Department of Defense investigations into detainee abuse allegations.


Interactive

Military 101Military 101
Basic training to learn all about America's fighting force.
Military 101

News Tools

AfghanistanAfghanistan
Learn about the people, economy and history.
Afghanistan

RELATED STORIES & LINKS

Rumsfeld Rips U.N. Over Gitmo
Defense Secretary: Kofi Annan 'Flat Wrong' To Want Prison Shut Down
Rumsfeld Rips U.N. Over Gitmo

U.S. Rejects U.N. Call To Close Gitmo
Report Calls For Detainees To Be Tried Or Released
U.S. Rejects U.N. Call To Close Gitmo

U.N. Says Gitmo Should Be Closed
Report Calls For Detainees To Be Tried Or Released
U.N. Says Gitmo Should Be Closed

Iraqi Officials Condemn Abuse Images
Australian TV Airs New Video, Photos Purportedly Showing Abu Ghraib
Iraqi Officials Condemn Abuse Images

U.N. Report: U.S. Tortures Detainees
U.S. Officials Reject Draft Report About Guantanamo, Citing Errors
U.N. Report: U.S. Tortures Detainees

Gitmo Inmate Alleges U.S. Torture
Kuwaiti Prisoner: Military Using Harsh Tactics To End Hunger Strikes
Gitmo Inmate Alleges U.S. Torture




E-Mail This StoryPrintable VersionTag With del.icio.us


The Court-Martial Of Willie Brand

Tells Scott Pelley "I Am Not A Violent Person"


(Page 2 of 3)
March 5, 2006

Previous ImageNext Image


(CBS) 
"I could smell that I was looking at what I thought was a cover-up," says retired Army Col. Lawrence Wilkerson.

Back in Washington, Wilkerson smelled trouble, and so did his boss. Wilkerson was chief of staff to Secretary of State Colin Powell. In 2004, during the Abu Ghraib abuse scandal in Iraq, Powell asked Wilkerson to investigate how Americans had come to torture.

"I was developing the picture as to how this all got started in the first place, and that alarmed me as much as the abuse itself because it looked like authorization for this abuse went to the very top of the United States government," says Wilkerson.

In 2002, the "top of the government" was divided over whether the Geneva Convention applied to prisoners in Afghanistan. The resulting presidential directive tried to have it both ways ordering that the "Öarmed forces shall continue to treat detainees humanely" but Geneva would apply only "to the extent appropriate and consistent with military necessity...."

Itís Wilkersonís opinion that the Army chose to ignore Geneva when it issued new rules for interrogations in Afghanistan and Iraq.

"That essentially says to the troops at the bottom of the rung that you have a new game," Wilkerson says. "You can use the methods that arenít in accordance with Geneva. You can use methods that are other than when youíve been taught, trained and told you could use. That, that is an invitation, a license to go beyond that, especially when youíre also putting on them tremendous pressure to produce intelligence."

Capt. Beiring acknowledges that there was some confusion. "Because a lot of people didnít really know, what are their status? Who are these people? Did they sign the Geneva Convention? Who are they and what do we do with them? So there was some confusion," he says.

"Can you tell me whether anyone up the chain of command above you was aware that the prisoners were being shackled with their hands up about shoulder high?" Pelley asked.

"Absolutely," Beiring said.

"Who knew?" Pelley asked.

"Several of my leaders knew because we had them like that, you know, there was probably one or two like that any given day. And we didnít change the procedure if someone came through whether they were a colonel or a general, we left them the same. They seen (sic) what was going on there," Beiring answered.

Pelley asked Brand if other leaders knew what was going on.

Gen. Daniel McNeill, the top officer in Afghanistan, said ďwe are not chaining people to the ceilings.Ē

Brand disagreed. "Well, heís lying obviously. I mean because we were doing it on a daily basis," he says.

"Gen. Theodore Nicholas, he was the top military intelligence officer in Afghanistan said that he did not recall prisoners being shackled with their arms overhead. Is that reasonable?" Pelley asked.

"No," Brand replied.

"Lt. Col. Ronald Stallings told investigators, quote, 'he had no idea,' end quote, that prisoners were being chained overhead for 24 hours and more. What you seem to be saying is that it was common knowledge," Pelley said.

"Yes," Brand said.

"It wasnít being kept a secret from the chain of command?" Pelley asked.

"No," Brand replied.

We donít know whether Gen. McNeill toured the prison, Brand doesnít specifically remember him there. But Gen. Nicholas and Lt. Col. Stallings were there. 60 Minutes wanted to speak with all three, but they declined.

There were inspection tours at the prison, run by the Red Cross. But the Red Cross didnít see everything. For example, it didnít see the instructions written on a dry erase board that told the guards how long prisoners were to be chained.

"We didnít want them to know ó we didnít think they had an operational reason to know," says Capt. Beiring. "It also had other things on there like if a detainee was fighting or being punished for doing stuff wrong or if he didnít eat his food or he wasnít drinking, but yes, we erased that board so the ICRC we didnít think they had the need to know."

There was a lot the Red Cross didnít know. Medical experts say that Dilawarís injuries were so severe that, if he had lived, both his legs would have required amputation. Even worse, one soldier testified that most of the interrogators thought Dilawar had been arrested only because he was in the wrong place at the wrong time. They had come to believe he was just a cab driver.


Continued
   1  |  2  |   3  




By Shawn Efran ©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.


INSIDE 60 Minutes
A Fighting Chance
Scott Pelley On Combat Medicine And The Battle To Save Lives
Charlie Weis: Big Man On Campus
The Explosion At Texas City
Calling All 'All Banians'
• More

TOP STORIES
Kerry Apologizes For Troop Remarks
Said He Didn't Mean To 'Imply Anything Negative About Those In Uniform'
6 Killed In Reno Hotel Fire
Bush: Rumsfeld And Cheney To Stay
Dad Found Guilty Of Genital Mutilation
• More


Back To Top Back To Top



Advertisement

Go To CBS News Video




RELATED VIDEO

Watch VideoPelley's Reporter's Notebook | Email this video

Watch VideoWillie Brand's Court-Martial | Email this video

60 MINUTES VIDEOSAll 60 Minutes Videos


Watch VideoA Fighting Chance  | Email this video

Watch VideoBig Man On Campus | Email this video

Watch VideoMedical Care In Iraq | Email this video

Watch VideoCities And Towns | Email this video

TOP VIDEOSAll Videos


Watch VideoFirst Look: Election Run-Up | Email this video

Watch VideoOn Tape: Cop Dodges Bull | Email this video

Watch VideoKerry Does Damage Control | Email this video

Watch Video6 Die In Reno Hotel Fire | Email this video

More Video


    Wireless Alerts:  CBS News To Go  E-Mail Sign-Up:  Breaking News  |  Today On CBS News  |  60 Minutes  |  48 Hours  |  The Early Show  |  CBS Sunday Morning  |  News Summaries

    Recommended Sites:  CBS Corporation  |  The ShowBuzz  |  CBS.com  |  CBS SportsLine  |  CWTV.com  |  ETOnline.com  |  The INSIDER  |  CBS Store  |  CBS Careers  |  CBS Cares
    Site Map  |  Video Site Map  |  RSS Feeds  |  Help  |  Advertise With Us  |  Contact Us  |  Terms of Service  |  Privacy Policy  |  CBS Bios  |  Internships
US News & World News
Stories Videos The Web  

©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.